There is a stretch in most fundraises where nothing seems to happen. Eleven days of “still working through our process.” No pass, no term sheet.
It is not a pause. The deal went underground.
Someone at the fund is on the phone with a former employee you have not spoken to in three years. A partner texted two investors who passed on your last round. Someone found the co-founder who left in year one and is not in the deck.
Team is the main thing early investors are betting on. So diligence on the team is the diligence. Your metrics get an afternoon in a spreadsheet. Your character gets two weeks of phone calls.
The five channels
- On-list references. The names you gave. Investors assume these will be glowing, so they weigh them lowest. The bar is not praise. It is specific praise.
- Customer references. Sometimes from your list, often not. Your logos are on your website.
- Former colleagues. Anyone who overlapped with you at your last two companies can be found in minutes.
- Co-investors. Your current backers, and the investors who passed on you. Passing investors talk.
- Backchannel. Ex-co-founders, early employees who left, former board members. This is where deals die quietly.
Many firms start these calls after the first or second meeting. If you are three meetings in, assume they have started.
The questions they ask
A good reference call is fifteen minutes of friendly conversation built around a few questions that make polite people reveal things without feeling like they said anything negative.
- “Would you work with them again?” The sharpest question. Hesitation is the answer.
- “Is this person in the top 5 percent of people you’ve worked with? Top 10? Top 25?” Almost everyone will place someone in a bucket. “Top quartile” sounds like a compliment. To the investor, it means good, not exceptional.
- “What’s something I won’t hear from them directly?”
- “How do they handle being wrong? Tell me about a specific disagreement.”
- “Walk me through why they left.”
- “Who else should I talk to?” The quiet one. Every call creates the next two.
Patterns that end deals
Investors are not grading content. They are grading pattern: tone, speed, specificity, consistency.
- The enthusiasm gap. Praise in the past tense and in general terms. “She was great” instead of “let me tell you about the time she.”
- Anything other than an instant yes to “would you work with them again?” “In the right role.” “Depends on the stage.” All honest, all scored as a no.
- Competence deflection. Asked about leadership, the reference talks about work ethic.
- Story mismatch. You said the co-founder split was amicable. They heard otherwise. The divergence is the flag.
- The non-answer. “I’d rather not get into that.” Declining to defend is read as the accusation.
- Small inflations. A founder who rounds up their history is assumed to round up their metrics.
- Dead air on “who else should I talk to?”
Notice what is not on the list: direct criticism. That rarely kills a deal. What does is the gap between what a supporter should sound like and what your references sound like. You do not lose the backchannel by having enemies. You lose it by having tepid friends.
Run your own backchannel first
Block 90 minutes.
- Build the list a motivated associate would build: every co-founder from every venture, your first ten employees and who left, your last two managers, every investor who passed after a real process, former board members and advisors, your five biggest customers plus one that churned, anyone you had a public conflict with.
- Score every name: Advocate (instant yes, tells a story), Neutral (polite and vague), Risk (different story, open conflict). Neutral counts as mildly negative. Fine is not fine.
- For each Risk, choose one: a repair call, a pre-emptive disclosure, or building enough strong advocates around it that it reads as an outlier.
- For the three or four most sensitive facts in your history, write the one-paragraph version you tell investors. Then ask whether everyone who witnessed it would tell a compatible one.
A repair call can sound like: “I’m raising, and people may reach out to folks we both worked with. Before that happens, I wanted to talk about how things ended, because I don’t think I handled it well.” You are not asking them to lie. You are closing the gap between versions.
If you disclose something first, it reads as maturity. If the backchannel finds it first, it reads as a cover-up.
Brief the references you do list
Send each one a short note before the calls. Say who is calling, what the round is about, and what the investor is really testing. Point to a specific story they saw up close. Warn them about questions like “would you work with them again” so they answer without hesitating. Ask for honesty.
Give different references different stories. Five people telling the same anecdote reads as coached. Never list someone who might hesitate.
Flip it
Before you sign, run the same process on your investor. Talk to five to seven founders: a couple the firm gave you, a couple you find yourself, and at least one from a portfolio company that struggled or shut down. Ask what the partner did during the down round, the co-founder blowup, the missed quarter. Diligence the specific partner joining your board, not just the brand.
The calls will happen without you. Do the work before they do.